After making a cake mess, throwing the pans in the garbage sounds like a pretty sweet plan!īut, the most surprising discovery was the exact tie between Fat Daddio’s and Wilton brands. Also, we’ve all wished we had some disposable foil pans at some point in our lives.

First, I didn’t know Dollar Tree sold cake pans.

1st – Fat Daddio’s and Wilton (Tied with 115 votes) 2nd– Williams Sonoma Gold Touch (26 votes) 3rd– Nordic Ware (22 votes) 4th – USA Pans and Magic Line (tied with 19 votes) 5th – Chicago Metallic (15 votes) 6th – Pans inherited from Grandma or Mom (8 votes) 7th – Calphalon (4 votes) 8th – Pyrex (3 votes) 9th– Dough Makers and Target (2 votes) 10th – Cuisinart, Betty Crocker, Baker’s Secret, Pampered Chef, Salad Master, PME, Last Confection, Cake Boss, Ateco, Disposable Foil, Dollar Tree, Walmart, Ovenex, Jamie Oliver, and Demarle (tied with 1 vote). We asked people to vote for their favorite cake pan and with hundreds of comments, we tallied them up. Wanting to test a variety of pans, we consulted our Instagram community to help us decide which pans to include. We knew this information would help us be better bakers! So, we held our first ever Cake Pan Showdown. With the incredibly vast selection of cake pans filling store shelves, we found ourselves wanting to do a little research to find the very best one.

Parrish magic line loaf pans